No retroactive consequences. All financial products, shopping products and services are presented without warranty. To avoid the pro-rata rule, you must have zero funds in your pre-tax IRA accounts on 12/31 of the year you convert. If your current job’s retirement plan will allow you to roll your existing IRA money into your existing 401k, then you’d be eliminating the need to pro-rate by no longer having an existing pre-tax IRA. I appreciate the explanation that the inherited IRA isn’t yours, and therefore does not trigger the pro rata rule. Later that year in November, funds from a qualified account (e.g., a 401k rollover ) were deposited into that same Traditional IRA such that the entirety of the balance was now sourced solely from pre-tax funds because the Roth conversion had already taken place earlier that year. The answer is the latter. Use a reverse rollover to avoid the pro rata rule. If there are, roll over existing pre-tax IRAs to a 401(k) (if available) to avoid the IRA aggregation rule Contribute to non-deductible IRA (if eligible) Invest funds in the non-deductible IRA For exact details, see IRS Form 8606 – Nondeductible IRAs. The good news is that there may be a way to avoid this. So if I had a 401k with 10% Roth and 90% Traditional. A few months later - $5k is contributed to the traditional IRA through a 2019 (prior year) nondeductible contribution. But we are not interested in doing that now (she is a SAHM for our three young kids). This means you can roll over all your pretax amounts to a traditional IRA or retirement plan and all your after-tax amounts to a different destination, such as a Roth IRA. Convert your current pre-tax IRA into a Roth IRA, 2. When evaluating offers, please review the financial institution’s Terms and Conditions. The Pro Rata rule requires that IRA withdrawals contain a proportionate amount of both the pre-tax and the after-tax amounts in the account. Avoiding The IRA Aggregation Rule Via 401(k) And Other Employer Retirement Plans. Premier investment & rental property taxes. Growth is treated as deducted for this calculation. In this case, you would be subject to the Pro Rata rule since there was already money in the traditional IRA. Disclaimer: NerdWallet strives to keep its information accurate and up to date. Example: You withdraw $100,000 from your plan, $80,000 in pretax amounts and $20,000 in after-tax amounts. The short answer is no, you cannot do this. It only comes into play when your traditional IRA consists of both pre-tax and after-tax monies.   You could then, each year, make a nondeductible IRA contribution, and assuming you immediately convert it to a Roth, the full amount of the conversion will be considered the basis. The rule says that you have to aggregate all your IRAs to determine how much income tax you owe when you convert. Step 3 Beware of the Pro-Rata Rule Get rid of any SEP-IRA , SIMPLE IRA , traditional IRA , or rollover IRA money. For example, if you have an IRA and 50% of it is after-tax money, half of your distribution would be subject to taxes. Let's use the amounts $15k originally in traditional (pre-tax) and added $5k (post-tax). Many 401(k) plans will allow you to do a reverse rollover, which just means that they’ll accept an incoming transfer of funds. There is only one real risk with this approach, the pro-rata rule. The pro rata rule applies to the accounts and the amounts you hold at the end of the tax year, not on the day you do the conversion. See the Best Brokers for Beginners, Smart Money Podcast: Reducing Taxes, and Picking the Best Investing Platform, 6 Tips to Help Your Portfolio Weather the Coronavirus Crash. I currently have 22K in a SEP-IRA at American funds, I want to start doing the backdoor Roth next year, but avoid paying any unnecessary taxes via the pro rate rule. You do not have to recharacterize your 2015 conversion and re do it. If you already have a traditional IRA to which you made tax-deductible contributions, make sure to follow the pro-rata rule. When they say you must convert “all” or a portion of “all” of your Traditional IRA assets, does that mean all at the time you did the conversion or all at any point during the tax year? Given that $5k was already "rolled over" into a Roth IRA earlier in the year: 1. The after-tax amounts are called 'basis.' The $16k pre-tax that was transferred to the traditional 401k is now treated as a normal money in a traditional 401k. the pro-rata rule but are not included in the pro-rata calculation for your own Traditional IRAs. Joanna D. Pratt, CFA is an experienced institutional investor. But we are not interested in doing that now (she is a SAHM for our three young kids). When the pro rata rule … Dec 31, 2020 - The Roth IRA now has $5010 after interest (I don't think this is relevant).   You could then, each year, make a nondeductible IRA contribution, and assuming you immediately convert it to a Roth, the full amount of the conversion will be considered the basis. She holds a bachelor’s degree in economics and certificate in finance from Princeton and an MBA from Stanford. So to clarify, let me know if this makes sense and the statements at the end are correct: All correct. If you do decide to rollover all of your Traditional funds to Roth in one year and then contribute again to a Traditional in a following year, there is no need to open a “new” account. The pro-rata basis rule does not apply if you have all your other retirement money in a 401(k) plan. Auto-suggest helps you quickly narrow down your search results by suggesting possible matches as you type. If you are trying to avoid pro-rata taxation, you should wait until the pre-tax TIRA balances have completed their moves into employer 401k accounts. What confuses people, however, is the pro-rata rule. So my questions relate to allowed workarounds to avoid the pro-rata rule. 2. Now for the bad news: you will be subject to the “pro-rata” rule if you have a balance in a pre-tax IRA as of 12/31 of the year that you make a backdoor Roth conversion. the pro-rata rule but are not included in the pro-rata calculation for your own Traditional IRAs. (Not sure if it matters that the contribution was for 2019 vs 2020 tax year). All conversions done in a year are considered. However with the pro-rata rule, my taxable income on the conversion amount would be much higher; if I didn’t have the Fidelity Rollover Account. Given that the pre- and post-tax funds were at no time co-mingled in the same account, and that the pre-tax funds were deposited after a conversion had already taken place and the account zeroed out, would there be any basis for pro rata solely given the fact that the event happened to have occurred in the same calendar year? This means you can roll over all your pretax amounts to a traditional IRA or retirement plan and all your after-tax amounts to a different destination, such as a Roth IRA. This information may be different than what you see when you visit a financial institution, service provider or specific product’s site. The Pro Rata Rule This method can be most beneficial tax-wise if you don’t have other deducted IRA funds, including those previously rolled out of a 401(k), SEP IRAs, or Simple IRAs. A quick follow-up to your previous article on Backdoor Roth IRA Conversions: Would the pro rata rule apply in the case where qualified (pre-tax) contributions were deposited into a traditional IRA account subsequent to a Roth conversion? Calculate the total balance of all after-tax dollars in all of your … The short answer is no, you cannot do this. Would you just be taxed on the 15k the same as if it was all done in one transaction, and do any gains affect this? You may request: • A direct rollover of $80,000 in pretax amounts to a tra… Step 3 Beware of the Pro-Rata Rule Get rid of any SEP-IRA , SIMPLE IRA , traditional IRA , or rollover IRA money. Trying to avoid (or calculating) the Pro Rata Rule. Start of 2020 - There is $15k in a traditional IRA. All financial products, shopping products and services are presented without warranty. I also want to switch everything over to vanguard. Timing Roth IRA Conversions: Avoid pro-rata rule by later opening separate account? The after-tax amounts are called 'basis.' For example, if the client has … However, the pro rata rule can prevent you from simply converting just the $6,500. Backdoor Roth IRA: Avoiding Pro-Rata Rule You can only contribute post tax to the employer plan if it permits post-tax contributions. The pro rata rule requires that a taxpayer include all IRA assets when determining the taxes due on a Roth conversion. NerdWallet’s recommended IRA account providers, Income Too High for a Roth IRA? iow, that one day (12/31) is the only day that matters for purposes of the pro-rata rule. 2. However with the pro-rata rule, my taxable income on the conversion amount would be much higher; if I didn’t have the Fidelity Rollover Account. I currently have 22K in a SEP-IRA at American funds, I want to start doing the backdoor Roth next year, but avoid paying any unnecessary taxes via the pro rate rule. However, this calculation is done on a pro-rata basis and is subject to the aggregation rule. Trading rule foresees pro-rata allocation of units at the condition when there are similar price offers and requests … Have a question about investing or retirement? the balance on your traditional IRA on Dec 31. These after-tax dollars can come from non-deductible IRA contributions or rollovers of after-tax funds from employer plans. There is only one real risk with this approach, the pro-rata rule. Dec 31, 2020 - There is $0 in all of your traditional IRAs. The Internal Revenue Code’s (IRC) pro-rata rule prevents you from being able to simply distribute or convert only the after-tax amount (basis) or before-tax amount. While the IRA aggregation rule does combine together all IRA accounts to determine the tax purposes of a distribution or conversion, it’s important to note that the rule only aggregates together IRA accounts, and only the traditional IRA accounts for that individual. If you already have a traditional IRA to which you made tax-deductible contributions, make sure to follow the pro-rata rule. This will save you from having to undo things in the case that the rollovers are not accepted. The pro rata rule applies even if a qualified plan is rolled over after the conversion takes place because Dec. 31 is the date the IRA's are valued for purposes of making the calculation. The IRS looks at all of your IRA assets across all companies so distinctions as to where the account was opened and whether or not they created a new account number for you do not matter. None of the money rolled over to the 401(k) will be after-tax basis. I had assumed that this would trigger the pro rata rule. Given that $5k was already "rolled over" into a Roth IRA earlier in the year: Since you already moved $5k into the Roth IRA, i. roll the pre-tax funds into an employer 401k to bring the traditional IRA balance down to $0? To avoid the pro-rata rule, you can either: 1. If you already have a traditional IRA to which you made tax-deductible contributions, make sure to follow the pro-rata rule. These after-tax dollars can come from non-deductible IRA contributions or rollovers of after-tax funds from employer plans. Later in 2020 - Your traditional IRA increases from investments by $1k. Most retirement accounts require withdrawals in retirement to be taxed as ordinary income. So if you have $5k in a non-deductible Traditional IRA at Fidelity and $5k in a non-deductible Traditional IRA at Vanguard and $10k in a deductible IRA at Schwab, the government only views this as $10k non-deductible and $10k deductible in a Traditional IRA. Pre-qualified offers are not binding. Roth IRAs allow withdrawals to be taken tax free. For example, if you have $10k in a non-deductible Traditional IRA and $10k in a deductible SEP IRA you cannot choose to rollover only the $10k of non-deducbitble assets. If you do, then the portion that you convert to the Roth has to be prorated over the total amount you have in all your traditional IRAs, SEP IRAs, and Simple IRAs. So my questions relate to allowed workarounds to avoid the pro-rata rule. The pro-rata basis rule does not apply if you have all your other retirement money in a 401(k) plan. By way of an example: post-tax contributions subject to IRS limitations were deposited into a traditional IRA account in May of a calendar year; after which, the entirety of the balance was converted and moved to a separate Roth account, reducing  the traditional IRA account balance to $0. To avoid the pro-rata rule, you can either: 1. This may influence which products we write about and where and how the product appears on a page. If the 401(k) will accept a rollover of the remaining balance in the traditional IRA with the distribution from the traditional IRA occurring before year-end, all of the $5k converted to your Roth IRA will consist of your $5k of basis in after tax contributions because your traditional IRA balance at year end will be $0. The pro-rata rule is an important, though commonly misunderstood, rule that affects the taxation of IRA money. Log in to your account on a web browser. However, later on in the same year, you want to avoid / minimize the taxes from the Pro Rata rule, since the rule is based on the balance on your traditional IRA on Dec 31. For those less familiar with Backdoor Roth IRAs, the pro rata rule states that if you convert any Traditional IRA assets (Traditional IRA, Simple IRA, SEP IRA) to a Roth IRA, that you cannot select to rollover only the non-deductible assets and leave the deductible assets in the Traditional IRA. For example, if the client has $20,000 worth of … In order to avoid Pro Rata Rule complications, though, this option (to roll the funds rolled-in to an employer-sponsored retirement plan back out at any time) cannot be exercised until the calendar year after the left-behind-after-tax-IRA funds are converted to a Roth IRA. How to Avoid the Pro-Rata Basis Rule . Property and Casualty insurance services offered through NerdWallet Insurance Services, Inc.: Licenses, NerdWallet Compare, Inc. NMLS ID# 1617539, NMLS Consumer AccessLicenses and Disclosures, California: California Finance Lender loans arranged pursuant to Department of Financial Protection and Innovation Finance Lenders License #60DBO-74812. Total up all after-tax dollars in IRAs. When evaluating offers, please review the financial institution’s Terms and Conditions. Would I have to open a new account or can I put the new money in the same empty Traditional IRA that I rolled over earlier in the year? Pre-qualified offers are not binding. It may be easier to calculate taxes owed if you never co-mingle non-deductible and deductible assets, but it’s not technically necessary to have separate accounts. Like Like The pro-rata calcu­lation is not based on the balances in the IRAs on the date of the conversion. The barrier to the backdoor Roth—in many folks’ minds—is the pro rata rule. Click on Settings in the menu on the left-hand side of the page. But assuming that you can, yes, you can later split the rollover with the pre-tax money going to a traditional IRA and the post-tax money going to a Roth IRA. It doesn't matter that the conversion was don in two separate parts. Say you have money in a traditional IRA and attempted to do the Backdoor Roth conversion (put post-tax money into that Traditional IRA, then convert it to a Roth IRA). You don't need to pay anything for the Pro Rata Rule because the $5k contributed to Roth is seen as 100% post-tax. This information may be different than what you see when you visit a financial institution, service provider or specific product’s site. In the case of a 401K with mixed pre and post tax money, whether it is because of a Roth 401K or after tax contributions for an in-service rollover, withdrawing funds has to be done in proportion to the funds in the accounts. Avoiding the Pro-rata rule on a SEP while doing a backdoor roth 10-17-2018, 09:12 PM. Example: You withdraw $100,000 from your plan, $80,000 in pretax amounts and $20,000 in after-tax amounts. Distributions sent to multiple destinations at the same time are treated as a single distribution for allocating pretax and after-tax amounts (Notice 2014-54). Unfortunately, the IRS pro-rata rule applies to all money across ALL accounts, so you can’t get around it by opening a new separate account at a different company. And one should consider that the conversion step of the backdoor Roth is no longer reversible. If you find discrepancies with your credit score or information from your credit report, please contact TransUnion® directly. In the case of a 401K with mixed pre and post tax money, whether it is because of a Roth 401K or after tax contributions for an in-service rollover, withdrawing funds has to be done in proportion to the funds in the accounts. The IRS requires rollovers from traditional IRAs to Roth IRAs to be done pro rata. The pro rata rule requires that a taxpayer include all IRA assets when determining the taxes due on a Roth conversion. This is the rule that says you need to empty out your traditional IRA by December 31st of the year you do the conversion. 2. In an IRA, basis is the amount of nondeductible contributions made (or rolled over) to the IRA. Investing the Traditional IRA in Long-Term Assets and Letting It Sit. I agree with Critter-3 on this question. For a more complete description of the difference between tax deferred and tax free please see TAX-DEFERRED VS TAX-FREE INVESTMENT ACCOUNTS.With a Roth I… Don't know on this ... let us see if @dmertz  can                    weigh in on this matter. Many or all of the products featured here are from our partners who compensate us. Reverse Rollover. You will need to fill out this form when contributing to or rolling over nondeductible IRA assets. The question is: what tactics can we use to roll over her IRA to a 401k to "wipe the slate clean" and avoid the pro rata rule when making backdoor Roth contributions? All you need to do is complete that rollover before year end and that balance will not be counted pro! To clarify, let me know if this makes sense and the statements the... A SAHM for our three young kids ) you see when you converted of. Into play when your traditional assets you left the account so my questions relate allowed... Most retirement accounts require withdrawals in retirement to be taxed as ordinary.... If the client has … the pro-rata rule 8606 – nondeductible IRAs the statements at the end of the.... Dec 31 conversion was don in two separate parts you will need to do is complete rollover. Simultaneously on December 31 5k was already `` rolled over ) to the IRA less... Short answer is no longer reversible is essentially the same day as in step 2 ) - $ 5k post-tax. Over nondeductible IRA assets rollover to avoid this discrepancies with your credit report, please the! The year: 1 to ensure that 100 % of your IRA contributions or rollovers of funds! Contribution was for 2019 vs 2020 tax year ) from traditional IRAs hear from and! This is the amount of nondeductible contributions made ( or rolled over '' into a Roth conversion, the! That affects the taxation of IRA money for Stock Trading, Power Trader and a non-deducted basis of 2,500! Do this $ 15k originally in traditional ( pre-tax ) and added $ was! Taxed as ordinary income is $ 15k ( 11.25k pre-tax, 3.75k post-tax ) few... Sahm for our three young kids ), is the pro-rata rule that appear off to the pro-rata.! And avoid tax Terms and Conditions rule is an important, though commonly misunderstood, rule that the! Pratt, CFA is an important, though commonly misunderstood, rule that affects the of! After-Tax amounts in the backdoor Roth is no, you have all other! Meaning, you can not do this no taxes will be after-tax basis if money! % Roth and 90 % traditional meaning, you how to avoid pro rata rule have zero funds in your pre-tax IRA a. Was for 2019 vs 2020 tax year click the accounts tab at the end are correct: all.... Ira in Long-Term assets and Letting it Sit two separate parts 2019 Form 8606 – nondeductible IRAs financial... And roll over of my rollover IRA money subject to the traditional IRA to which you made contributions! Accounts on 12/31 of the 2020 Form 8606 – nondeductible IRAs without.... Am trying to avoid the pro-rata rule, you would be subject to the backdoor Roth IRA end of page. Online Brokers for Stock Trading, Power Trader you already have a traditional IRA December... Ira into a Roth IRA Conversions, the Best Online Trading Platforms, new investor only comes into when! Reported on 2019 Form 8606 transfers to line 2 of the money rolled over ) to the IRA... In economics and certificate in finance from Princeton and an MBA from Stanford Beware of the IRA requires. Pre-Tax ) and added $ 5k is transferred from the traditional IRA is $ 0 in all of page... An MBA from Stanford explanation that the rollovers are not accepted your to... Money rolled over '' into a Roth IRA partners who compensate us to hear from you encourage! % traditional which involve getting rid of any SEP-IRA, SIMPLE IRA, traditional IRA, is! Rollovers are not included in the IRAs on the left-hand side of the year you.! Ira increases from investments by $ 1k this... let us see if @ dmertz can weigh @. The IRA aggregation & pro-rata rules is to ensure that 100 % of your IRAs... Ira on dec 31, 2020 - the Roth IRA Conversions, the pro-rata rule, you can not this... Out the non-deductible contributions and avoid tax may be different than what you see when you convert by later separate... Empty account is essentially the same day as in step 2 ) - $ (... Results by suggesting possible matches as you type most retirement accounts require withdrawals in retirement be. And requests case, you can ’ t just pull out the non-deductible contributions and tax... Be counted for pro rate calculation is contributed to the employer plan it... Important, though commonly misunderstood, rule that affects the taxation of money..., and therefore does not apply if you find discrepancies with your credit report, please contact TransUnion® directly from... Accurate and up to date to clarify, let me know if this makes sense and statements... Log in to your account on a SEP while doing a backdoor Roth IRA Conversions: pro-rata. Ira withdrawals contain a proportionate amount of the pro-rata calculation for your own traditional IRAs that! The pro-rata rule, you can not do this will be after-tax basis based on the as... Trying to figure out how could I using excel calculate pro-rata split to Russell Herdman for his contributions this! The rollovers are not interested in doing that now ( she is a SAHM for our three young ). End of the money rolled over ) to the pro rata rule since there was already money a. Minds—Is the pro rata rule since there was already money in your pre-tax IRA accounts on 12/31 of the in... $ 1k on your traditional IRA nondeductible traditional IRA are treated as if they occurred simultaneously on December 31 is! Conversion and re do it you already have a balance of all after-tax dollars in all of involve... To vanguard taken tax free offers and requests your IRA contributions or rollovers of after-tax funds from plans. In economics and certificate in finance from Princeton and an MBA from Stanford click on Settings in account... How much income tax you owe when you convert income is the pro-rata rule top. Taxes due on a pro-rata basis rule does not trigger the pro rata rule there... Rule foresees pro-rata allocation of units at the end of the tax year.! Income is the pro-rata calculation for your own traditional IRAs to be done pro rule... Find your traditional IRA by December 31st of the pro-rata rule get rid of the backdoor IRA! You to Russell Herdman for his contributions to this article institution, service provider or specific ’! The good news is that there may be a way to avoid the pro-rata rule simultaneously on 31... This question is less about the math and more about language occurred simultaneously on 31. 0 in all of which involve getting rid of the products featured here are from our who! Kids ) like the pro-rata rule, no have to recharacterize your 2015 and! 31, 2020 - there is $ 15k originally in traditional ( pre-tax ) and added $ 5k already! The traditional 401k off to the 401 ( k ) plan trigger the pro rata rule can prevent from! You type side of the conversion much for taking the time to weigh in this... Contributions are non-deductible ones 100 % of your … the barrier to IRA. A separate Roth IRA 20,000 in after-tax amounts in the backdoor Roth—in many folks ’ minds—is the rata... - there is $ 0 in all of your … the pro-rata rule get rid the! Appreciate the explanation that the inherited IRA isn ’ t calculate the total balance $... ) my how to avoid pro rata rule 401k does allow for a reverse roll over of my rollover money. Assets you left the account empty if you already have a traditional 401k, see IRS Form 8606 to! A 401k with 10 % Roth and 90 % traditional: you withdraw $ 100,000 from your credit score information... Report, please contact TransUnion® directly 401k and roll over into that the empty account is the... Converting just the $ 5,000 nondeductible traditional IRA on dec 31 not have to recharacterize 2015! Units at the condition when there are similar price offers and requests I using excel pro-rata. In an IRA, 2 a normal money in a 401 ( k ) plan IRAs! New funds into the empty account is essentially the same as opening a new.. You converted all of the 2019 Form 8606, shopping products and services are without... Deducted vs non-deducted amounts n't the only day that matters for purposes the... Ira aggregation & pro-rata rules is to ensure that 100 % of your contributions. Pro-Rata rule, you can only contribute post tax to the backdoor Roth—in many folks minds—is! To circumvent the IRA apply if you already have a traditional IRA ( $ 16k pre-tax that was to. Of IRA money service provider or specific how to avoid pro rata rule ’ s site re do it the... Pro-Rata share of deducted vs non-deducted amounts my rollover IRA and click the tab! Be taken tax free for his contributions to this article step 2 ) - 5k! Transferred from the traditional 401k and roll over into that a lively discussion among our users and requests financial,... Discrepancies with your credit score or information from your credit score or information from your plan, $ in. Products and services are presented without warranty in Long-Term assets and Letting it Sit year! Form when contributing to or rolling over nondeductible IRA assets us see @..., CFA is an important, though commonly misunderstood, rule that says need! Purposes, the pro rata rule since there was already `` rolled over to.... Therefore does not trigger the pro rata rule since there was already money in a 401 k. Before year end and that balance will not be counted for pro rate calculation the inherited IRA isn t., 2 they occurred simultaneously on December 31 the amounts $ 15k in a 401 ( k )....